Patient Safety Primer
Medication Errors and Adverse Drug Events
Background and Definitions
Advances in clinical therapeutics have resulted in major improvements in health for patients with many diseases, but these benefits have also been accompanied by increased risks. A medication error is an error (of commission or omission) at any step along the pathway that begins when a clinician prescribes a medication and ends when the patient actually receives the medication. An adverse drug event (ADE) is defined as harm experienced by a patient as a result of exposure to a medication. As with the more general term adverse event, the occurrence of an ADE does not necessarily indicate an error or poor quality care. Preventable adverse drug events result from a medication error that reaches the patient and causes any degree of harm. It is generally estimated that about half of ADEs are preventable. Medication errors that do not cause any harm—either because they are intercepted before reaching the patient or because of luck—are often called potential ADEs. An ameliorable ADE is one in which the patient experienced harm from a medication that, while not completely preventable, could have been mitigated. Finally, a certain percentage of patients will experience ADEs even when medications are prescribed and administered appropriately; these are considered adverse drug reactions or nonpreventable ADEs (and are popularly known as side effects).
For example, the intravenous anticoagulant heparin is considered one of the highest-risk medications used in the inpatient setting. Safe use of heparin requires weight-based dosing and frequent monitoring of tests of the blood's clotting ability, in order to avoid either bleeding complications (if the dose is too high) or clotting risks (if the dose is inadequate). If a clinician prescribes an incorrect dose of heparin, that would be considered a medication error (even if a pharmacist detected the mistake before the dose was dispensed). If the incorrect dose was dispensed and administered but the patient experienced no clinical consequences, that would be a potential ADE. If an excessively large dose was administered, the overdose was detected by abnormal lab results, but the patient experienced a bleeding complication due to clinicians failing to respond appropriately, that would be considered an ameliorable ADE (that is, earlier detection could have reduced the level of harm the patient experienced).
Adverse drugs events are one of the most common preventable adverse events in all settings of care, mostly because of the widespread use of prescription and nonprescription medications. Clinicians have access to an armamentarium of more than 10,000 prescription medications, and nearly one-third of adults in the United States take 5 or more medications. Each year, ADEs account for nearly 700,000 emergency department visits and 100,000 hospitalizations. Nearly 5% of hospitalized patients experience an ADE, making them one of the most common types of inpatient errors. Ambulatory patients may experience ADEs at even higher rates, as illustrated by the dramatic increase in deaths due to opioid medications, which has largely taken place outside the hospital. Transitions in care are also a well-documented source of preventable harm related to medications.
Risk Factors for Adverse Drug Events
There are patient-specific, drug-specific, and clinician-specific risk factors for ADEs. Polypharmacy—taking more medications than clinically necessary—is likely the strongest risk factor for ADEs. Elderly patients, who take more medications and are more vulnerable to specific medication adverse effects than younger patients, are particularly vulnerable to ADEs. Pediatric patients are also at heightened risk, especially when hospitalized, since many medications for children must be dosed according to their weight. Other well-documented patient-specific risk factors include limited health literacy and numeracy (the ability to use arithmetic operations for daily tasks). It is important to note that in ambulatory care, patient-level risk factors are probably an underrecognized source of ADEs. Studies have shown that both caregivers (including parents of sick children) and patients themselves commit medication administration errors at surprisingly high rates.
The Institute for Safe Medication Practices maintains a list of high-alert medications—medications that can cause significant patient harm if used in error. These include medications that have dangerous adverse effects, but also include look-alike and sound-alike medications: those that have similar names and physical appearance but completely different pharmaceutical properties. The Beers criteria, which define certain classes of medications as potentially inappropriate for geriatric patients, have traditionally been used to assess medication safety. However, the newer STOPP criteria (Screening Tool of Older Person's inappropriate Prescriptions) have been shown to more accurately predict ADEs than the Beers criteria and are therefore likely a better measure of prescribing safety in elderly patients.
Though there are specific types of medications for which the harm generally outweighs the benefits, such as benzodiazepine sedatives in elderly patients, it is now clear that most ADEs are caused by commonly used medications that have risks, but offer significant benefits if used properly. These medications include antidiabetic agents (e.g., insulin), oral anticoagulants (e.g., warfarin), antiplatelet agents (such as aspirin and clopidogrel), and opioid pain medications. Together, these four medications account for more than 50% of emergency department visits for ADEs in Medicare patients. Focusing on improving prescribing safety for these useful but higher-risk medications may reduce the burden of ADEs in elderly patients more than focusing on use of potentially inappropriate classes of medications.
The opioid epidemic—which was declared a public health emergency in 2017—has also brought to light the role of clinician-specific and health system factors in medication errors. Opioid prescribing has increased dramatically over the past 15 years, and recent research questions the benefit of this practice. For example, opioid prescribing after dental procedures and low-risk surgical procedures increased sharply between 2004 and 2012, despite lack of evidence for the benefit of opioids in these situations. Another study found wide variation in opioid prescribing practices between physicians in the same specialty. The reasons behind why physicians overprescribe opioids are complex, and they are explored in more detail in a 2016 PSNet Annual Perspective
Prevention of Adverse Drug Events
The pathway connecting a clinician's decision to prescribe a medication and the patient actually receiving the medication consists of several steps:
- Ordering: the clinician must select the appropriate medication and the dose, frequency, and duration.
- Transcribing: in a paper-based system, an intermediary (a clerk in the hospital setting, or a pharmacist or pharmacy technician in the outpatient setting) must read and interpret the prescription correctly.
- Dispensing: the pharmacist must check for drug–drug interactions and allergies, then release the appropriate quantity of the medication in the correct form.
- Administration: the correct medication must be supplied to the correct patient at the correct time. In hospitals or long-term care settings, this is generally the responsibility of nurses or other trained staff; in ambulatory care the responsibility falls to patients or caregivers.
The widespread use of electronic health records has helped avert errors at the ordering and transcribing stages, but these errors still persist, and studies have found a high rate of medication administration errors in both the inpatient and outpatient settings.
Preventing medication errors requires specific steps to ensure safety at each stage of the pathway (Table).
Table. Strategies to Prevent Adverse Drug Events
Although each of the strategies enumerated in the Table can prevent ADEs when used individually, improving medication safety cannot be divorced from the overall goal of reducing preventable harm from all causes. Analysis of serious medication errors invariably reveals underlying system flaws—such as human factors engineering issues and impaired safety culture—that allowed individual prescribing or administration errors to reach the patient and cause serious harm. Integration of information technology solutions (including computerized provider order entry and barcode medication administration) into "closed-loop" medication systems holds great promise for improving medication safety in hospitals, but the potential for error will remain unless these systems are carefully implemented and these larger issues are addressed.
Preventing ADEs is a major priority for health systems. The Joint Commission has named improving medication safety as a National Patient Safety Goal for both hospitals and ambulatory clinics, and the Partnership for Patients has included ADE prevention as one of its key goals for improving patient safety. The opioid epidemic has spurred the development of multiple initiatives to reduce inappropriate opioid prescribing, including enhanced prescription drug monitoring programs and updated prescribing guidelines for clinicians, as well as initiatives to mitigate risks associated with opioid use. These programs are summarized in a 2016 Annual Perspective and a 2017 PSNet perspective. The Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion issued the National Action Plan for Adverse Drug Event Prevention in 2014, which identified ways to align the efforts of federal health agencies to reduce patient harms from specific medications, including opioids. And in 2017, the World Health Organization launched its Medication Without Harm program as part of its Global Patient Safety Challenges initiative.